Car storage in Amherst, NY

Recommended

Best price, quality and distance

Cheap prices

Store your car as low as $45/month

Indoor & covered

Extra protection for your vehicle

Top-rated

Average rating of 4+ stars

Multiple vehicles

Storage for more than one car

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

84 spaces near Amherst

Parking Lot

20’ × 10’

5.0

Cheektowaga, NY

7.1 mi

near 51 Williamstowne Ct

Security Camera

No Stairs

$30/ mo

Storage space

20’ × 10’

5.0

Amherst, NY

0.4 mi

near 18 Millbrook Ct

Top Host

Security Camera

Attendant or Security

"Very nice folks and dedicated to providing great service!" －Verified review

$30

1st month

$60/ mo

Parking Lot

2 sizes available

5.0

Buffalo, NY

1.6 mi

near 144 Leonore Rd

20’ × 10’

$50/ mo

15’ × 10’

$50/ mo

20’ × 10’ starting at

$50

Average price of outdoor listings in Amherst: $91.5, with prices starting at $45.
Driveway spaces average $47 and are 29% of low-price listings.
First month discount available on 17% of listings, lowest at $45.

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Buffalo, NY

3.1 mi

near 63 Cottonwood Dr

Security Camera

$22.50

1st month

$45/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

5.0

Amherst, NY

1.4 mi

near Youngmann Expy

Locked Area

Private Space

No Stairs

$49/ mo

Parking Lot

10’ × 20’

5.0

Buffalo, NY

4.9 mi

near 172 Lee St

No Stairs

Private Space

$49/ mo

Average monthly cost of indoor covered car storage: $148.
Average host response time within 16 minutes; 50% of top hosts.
Most spaces are garages with 100% indoor exposure.

Garage

20’ × 10’

Buffalo, NY

3 mi

near 4 Ellicott Ct

Security Camera

Private Space

$200/ mo

Garage

20’ × 20’

2.7

Buffalo, NY

3.9 mi

near 89 Preston Rd

Security Camera

Private Entrance

Climate Controlled

Smoke Free

No Stairs

$96/ mo

75% of listings are outdoor and uncovered with a fast host response.
The average rating is 3.3 of 5, with most rated above 3.
Driveways average $75 monthly, and parking lots $50, both 20x10 feet.

Driveway

50’ × 20’

5.0

Buffalo, NY

4.7 mi

near 10 Amherston Dr

$100/ mo

Life Storage

4 sizes available

4.9

550 Cayuga Rd Buffalo, NY

3.1 mi

2.3x more expensive

Pros:

Quick and easy rental process
Clean and secure storage units
Friendly and professional service

Cons:

Employees mix up storage units
Storage locks damaged by staff
Large price increases without notice
Long wait times due to understaffing
Confusion over facility ownership

10'×15'

starting at

$226/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$226/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$259/ mo

10'×35'

starting at

$246/ mo

10'×20' starting at

$226

Life Storage

4 sizes available

4.9

1275 Sheridan Dr Buffalo, NY

4.8 mi

2.1x more expensive

Pros:

Convenient location with ample parking
Affordable prices for storage options
Clean and well-maintained facility
Excellent customer service experience

Cons:

No substantial cons mentioned

10'×15'

starting at

$228/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$227/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$181/ mo

10'×35'

starting at

$233/ mo

10'×25' starting at

$181

Average price for multiple vehicle storage is $130, with 83% of spaces outdoor.
50% of listings have a "Top Host" with response times averaging 100 minutes.
33% of listings are driveways, averaging 40 feet in length.

Unpaved Lot

25’ × 25’

Buffalo, NY

4.4 mi

near 645 E Delavan Ave

Private Space

No Stairs

$38.50

1st month

$77/ mo

Unpaved Lot

70’ × 10’

Cheektowaga, NY

4.8 mi

near 172 Lee St

Private Space

$95/ mo

Life Storage

2 sizes available

4.8

521 Young St Tonawanda, NY

4.3 mi

2.3x more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-lit facility
Friendly and helpful staff
Smooth and quick check-in process
Good security measures

Cons:

Regular rent increases incur
Facility not accessible 24/7
Required to purchase facility's lock
Inconsistent management and service antfikationɛnFriday<|disc_thread|><|disc_sep|>

10'×15'

starting at

$183/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$231/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$183

Average distance of 1.8 miles; 25% of listings within 1 mile.
67% of listings are Storage Units; 50% have drive-up access.
42% of hosts respond within 15 minutes; lowest price is $45.

Driveway

30’ × 85’

Amherst, NY

0.1 mi

near 18 Millbrook Ct

Private Space

$217/ mo

Public Storage

2 sizes available

4.8

3671 Sheridan Dr Buffalo, NY

0.4 mi

2.2x more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-maintained facility
Secure with no rodent problems
Conveniently located
Attentive and helpful staff
Facility recently remodeled

Cons:

Not open 24 hours
Front gate issues with the app
Unexpected price increases
Poor or missing signage

10'×15'

starting at

$198/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$200/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$198

Public Storage

2 sizes available

2750 Millersport Hwy Getzville, NY

3.5 mi

2.1x more expensive

Pros:

Fast and helpful customer service
Clean and professional facility
Easy to register and move in

Cons:

Prices frequently increase without notice
Insufficient moving equipment available
Gate possibly malfunctioning at times
Issues with insulation and unit accessibility

10'×15'

starting at

$166/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$174/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$166

Neighbor reviews in Amherst, New York

4.9 (106 reviews)

Based on 106 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding car storage in Amherst 4.9 out of 5 on average

Find nearby storage locations

Eggertsville, New York (1 mi)

Williamsville, New York (3 mi)

Getzville, New York (4 mi)

Kenmore, New York (4 mi)

Cheektowaga, New York (5 mi)

Tonawanda, New York (5 mi)

East Amherst, New York (6 mi)

Harris Hill, New York (6 mi)

Depew, New York (6 mi)

North Tonawanda, New York (6 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage facility cost comparison

	10×20	10×40
Average storage facility Amherst, NY	$195	$197
Neighbor 51 storage spaces nearby	$50	$217
Public Storage Buffalo, NY (0 miles)	$200	--
Life Storage Buffalo, NY (3 miles)	$226	--
Public Storage Getzville, NY (4 miles)	$174	--

Storage for Rent in Amherst, NY

Select storage type

Explore car storage in Amherst, New York

Indoor car storage

What type of vehicle storage is best for you?

Choose whether to store your vehicle using uncovered parking, covered parking, or an indoor storage unit. Each offers their own benefits and downsides.

Uncovered Parking

three cars parked together next to a field

Parking spaces are affordable options at commercial lots & residential properties.

Covered storage is typically slightly more expensive than uncovered storage in Amherst

Find outdoor parking

Covered Parking

boat on trailer with fabric cover in outdoor covered area

Covered parking provides a roof or partial enclosure around your car.

There are 200% more hosts in Amherst that are part of our Top Host program than surrounding cities

Find covered parking

Indoor Storage

Shared & private storage includes drive-up storage units, private garages & warehouses.

Indoor storage in Amherst is 166% more expensive than nearby areas

Find indoor storage

Additional New York car storage locations

2907 Rte 9w, New Windsor

9 South Lewis Street, Auburn

Carmans Road, Massapequa

131 Akron Street, Lindenhurst

Upper Whitfield Road, Accord

Alternative Car Storage Facilities near Amherst

While traditional storage facilities are commonly available in Amherst, New York, Neighbor.com usually has the lower-priced, safest, and closest car storage.

Look at the facilities below for information:

Life Storage (3.1 miles)

550 Cayuga Rd Buffalo, NY

Life Storage (4.3 miles)

521 Young St Tonawanda, NY

Life Storage - Buffalo (4.8 miles)

1275 Sheridan Dr Buffalo, NY

Lancaster Self Storage (5.5 miles)

6509 TRANSIT Rd Bowmansville, NY

Ikon Self Storage (9 miles)

1777 Union Rd West Seneca, NY

Public Storage (0.4 miles)