Car storage in East Setauket, NY

Recommended

Best price, quality and distance

Cheap prices

Store your car as low as $71/month

Indoor & covered

Extra protection for your vehicle

Top-rated

Average rating of 4+ stars

Multiple vehicles

Storage for more than one car

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

210 spaces near East Setauket

Unpaved Lot

36’ × 20’

5.0

Coram, NY

4.7 mi

near 16 Cammann Rd

Private Space

No Stairs

$109/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Centereach, NY

1.8 mi

near 165 Stuyvesant Dr

No Stairs

$72/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Setauket- East Setauket, NY

1 mi

near 54 N Belle Mead Rd

Private Space

The location is near Stony Brook University.

$75/ mo

Prices range between $71 to $129 per month.
58% of listings offer first month discount.
Driveways account for 83% of listings.

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Port Jefferson Station, NY

0.9 mi

near 28 Hart St

No Stairs

You can check your vehicle anytime you need to, just notify me beforehand.

$71/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Selden, NY

3.6 mi

near 15 Embassy Rd

Security Camera

No Stairs

$71/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

5.0

St James, NY

4.5 mi

near 40 Hobson Ave

Private Space

It's a safe neighborhood and a private space.

$36

1st month

$72/ mo

100% of listings offer indoor protection. 83% are in a garage.
Average response time: 24 minutes. All spaces have indoor exposure.
Prices: $249 on average for 20x20 spaces. Most spaces feature easy access.

Garage

20’ × 20’

Setauket- East Setauket, NY

1 mi

near 54 N Belle Mead Rd

Locked Area

No Stairs

Smoke Free

Private Space

$249/ mo

Average rating of 5.0 and rapid responses within 20 minutes on multiple listings.
Most listings are Storage Units with outdoor, climate-controlled features.
Average distance is 3.4 miles, with prices ranging from $72 to $787.

Public Storage

2 sizes available

4.8

550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

4.8 mi

58% more expensive

Pros:

Easy registration and setup process
Staff is very professional and helpful
Mobile entry app for easy access

Cons:

Significant rent increases over time
Costs could be high for long-term renters

10'×15'

starting at

$236/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$277/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$236

Prime Storage

7 sizes available

4.3

1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson Station, NY

2.4 mi

50% more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-maintained facility
Very secure with security measures
Friendly and helpful staff
Convenient location and accessible units

Cons:

Frequent and significant price increases
Some units not the advertised size
Difficulties with online payment processing
Inconsistent promotion and discount policies

10'×15'

starting at

$382/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$444/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$521/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

$642/ mo

10'×32'

starting at

$666/ mo

12'×20'

starting at

$242/ mo

12'×40'

starting at

$292/ mo

12'×20' starting at

$242

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Selden, NY

4.8 mi

near 151 Skyline Dr

Security Camera

No Stairs

Private Space

$36

1st month

$72/ mo

Prices range from $150 to $996 for multi-vehicle car storage.
Spaces available are typically 10-85 feet wide and 10-115 feet long.
Most popular: Unpaved Lots at $200 average, 4.4 miles from East Setauket.

Unpaved Lot

10’ × 20’

Farmingville, NY

4.8 mi

near 23 N Morris Ave

Security Camera

No Stairs

$89/ mo

Unpaved Lot

3 sizes available

Selden, NY

2.6 mi

near 659 Jayne Blvd

Fenced Property

No Stairs

20’ × 10’

$150/ mo

30’ × 10’

$175/ mo

40’ × 10’

$200/ mo

20’ × 10’ starting at

$150

Driveway

10’ × 20’

Farmingville, NY

4.7 mi

near 23 N Morris Ave

Security Camera

No Stairs

$99/ mo

Listings average 2 miles from East Setauket center, with 50% within 1.5 miles.
Average response time is 19 minutes for unpaved lots; 24 hours for other types.
42% of units have outdoor, uncovered exposure; 33% offer climate control, elevator.

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Centereach, NY

2.6 mi

near 33 Ruland Rd

Locked Area

Security Camera

Private Space

No Stairs

$455.50

1st month

$911/ mo

Driveway

20’ × 10’

Lake Grove, NY

3 mi

near 12 Marwood Pl

The driveway is clean and equipped with motion detector lights overseeing both the driveway and front door.

$100/ mo

Extra Space Storage

2 sizes available

4.8

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

4.4 mi

68% more expensive

Pros:

Units are clean and well-maintained.
Location is safe and secure.
Helpful and friendly staff.
Conveniently located with a variety of unit sizes.

Cons:

Website and online process can be confusing.
High curbs at some units.
Some units smaller than listed dimensions.

10'×15'

starting at

$339/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$312/ mo

10'×20' starting at

$312

Neighbor reviews in East Setauket, New York

Verified Review

"Edmir is the best possible host I could have asked for. ... He went above and beyond to help us out, and he was very good at communicating with us. ... You will not find a better neighbor than Edmir. ... I give him 5 out of 5 stars, and my only wish were I could give him 10 stars."

Richard R.

Boston, MA

Nov 28, 2022

Verified Review

"Easy and communicates very well!"

Julia S.

Boston, MA

Apr 27, 2023

Find nearby storage locations

Port Jefferson Station, New York (1 mi)

Terryville, New York (2 mi)

Stony Brook, New York (2 mi)

Port Jefferson, New York (3 mi)

Centereach, New York (3 mi)

Selden, New York (3 mi)

Mount Sinai, New York (4 mi)

Lake Grove, New York (4 mi)

Coram, New York (5 mi)

Miller Place, New York (5 mi)

Storage facility cost comparison

	10×20	10×30	10×40
Average storage facility East Setauket, NY	$351	$478	$271
Neighbor 100+ storage spaces nearby	$153	$175	$208
Prime Storage Port Jefferson Station, NY (2 miles)	$242	$292	$292
Extra Space Storage Coram, NY (4 miles)	$312	--	--
Public Storage Coram, NY (5 miles)	$277	--	--

Vehicle storage size estimator

Enter your car information below to see what size storage unit you need for your car.

Select Make

Select Model

Select Year

Recommended storage options by car type

Compact car

10’×15’ storage units

Due to their small size, mini cars can fit in an indoor or outdoor 10’×15’ space. Car examples include Mini Cooper (12.6 feet) and Mazda Miata (12.10 feet).

View compact car storage

Small car

10’×15’ storage units

Small car examples include Honda Fit (13.3 feet), Volkswagen Golf (13.8 feet), Kia Soul (13.9 feet), and Kia Rio Hatchback (13.4 feet).

View small car storage

Small SUV

10’×15’ storage units

Small SUVs can be stored indoor, outdoor, and covered spaces. The Toyota Corolla iM (14.2 feet) and Honda CR-V are car examples.

View small SUV storage

Mid-size car

10’×15’ storage units

Mid-size cars are the largest cars that fit in a 10’×15’ space. Examples include Ford Fiesta (14.5 feet), and Ford Focus (14.4 feet).

View mid-size car storage

Full-size car

10’×20’ storage units

Full-sized cars include Toyota Camry (16.2 feet), Honda Civic (15.27 feet), Ford Fusion (15.9 feet), and Chevrolet Impala (16.7 feet).

View full-size car storage

Small pickup

10’×20’ storage units

Small pickups can be stored uncovered and outdoor. If storing indoor, make sure the height of the car will work. Toyota Tacoma (17.6 feet) is a small pickup.

View small pickup storage

Mid-size to large SUV

10’×20’ storage units

Larger SUVs requiring a 10’×20’ unit include Jeep Grand Cherokee (16.13 feet), Toyota RAV4 (15.1 feet), GMC Sierra (19.1 feet), and Ford Explorer (16.5 feet).

View large SUV storage

Minivan

10’×20’ storage units

Minivans typically fit well in a 10’×20’ unit. For more room, store in a 10’×30’. Car examples include Honda Odyssey (17.1 feet) and Toyota Sienna (16.9 inches).

View minivan storage

Large pickup

10’×30’ storage units

Large pickup 10’×30’ storage units Pickup trucks can be store indoor or outdoor. Examples include Chevrolet Silverado (19.4 feet), Ford F-150 (18.97 feet), and the rest of the Ford-F series (20.85 feet).

View large pickup storage

Deciding what kind of storage is best for you

Seasonal car storage

Choose indoor storage (garage or facility) for protection, or secure outdoor storage with a cover. Maintain battery and tires.

Storing a car while in a large city

Use a secure parking garage, consider car storage services, or park in well-lit areas with anti-theft devices.

Military deployment car storage

Select a long-term storage facility with monitoring, trust friends or family, or consider renting it out for extra use.

Storing a business car or truck

Opt for commercial storage facilities, use on-site storage if available, and perform maintenance pre-storage.

Auto storage during a life change

Options include long-term storage facilities, trusted contacts (friends or family), or renting out the car for extra use.

Parking a car when you travel

Consider airport parking, storage facilities, or car storage services. Ensure your car is well-maintained before departure.

Can’t find what you’re looking for?

Search the nation’s largest storage marketplace to find cheap car storage near you.

See more car storage

Tips to prepare your car for storage

Properly preparing a car for short- or long-term storage prevents damage, maintains its value, saves on costs and makes pick-up easier

Clean the vehicle

Prevent damage from buildup and rust by cleaning the car's interior and exterior.

Fill fluids & stabilize

Fill coolant, brake fluid and transmission fluid. Fill the gas tank, add fuel stabilizer and drive for 15 minutes.

Change the oil

Avoid corrosion by changing the oil and filter and run the engine to circulate the fresh oil.

Protect your tires

Store on jack stands or tire saver ramps at a lower PSI or keep tires inflated and drive regularly.

Use a car cover

Store outdoors with a breathable, water-resistant, fitted cover that also covers the wheels.

Protect the battery

Disconnect the battery and store indoors or maintain the charge with a battery maintainer.

Seal openings

Keep rodents out - stuff the tailpipe, plug the air filter box intake duct and turn the A/C to “recycled air”.

Run the vehicle

Start the car and drive it periodically to circulate fluids and prevent flat spots on the tires.

See car storage options

Storage for Rent in East Setauket, NY

Select storage type

Explore car storage in East Setauket, New York

Indoor car storage

Additional New York car storage locations

186 S 8th St., Southside

Carmans Road, Massapequa

9 South Lewis Street, Auburn

377 Ocean Ave, Islip

164 Alda Drive, Kingston

Alternative Car Storage Facilities near East Setauket

While traditional storage options are commonly available in East Setauket, New York, Neighbor.com usually has the lower-priced, safest, and closest car storage.

Look at the facilities below for information:

Public Storage (4.8 miles)

550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

Extra Space Storage (4.4 miles)

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

Extra Space Storage (9 miles)

3016 Express Dr S Islandia, NY

Extra Space Storage (9.5 miles)

84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

Public Storage (6.4 miles)

922 Route 25A Miller Place, NY

Public Storage (9.7 miles)