Garages for rent in West Islip, NY
ft
Neighbor reviews near West Islip, NY
4.9 (392 reviews)
Based on 392 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding garages for rent in West Islip 4.9 out of 5 on average
J
James G.
-
Beverly, MA
Mar 4, 2025
Verified Review
Tony could not have been nicer and took better care of my car than I would have if I were storing it myself! ... If you're lucky enough to find an open space at Tony's garage, I wouldn't hesitate to grab it - before someone else does!
P
Paul G.
-
Marlboro, NY
Nov 3, 2023
Verified Review
Thank you again! Paul
T
Troy C.
-
Jamaica, NY
May 31, 2023
Verified Review
Jamaal F.
-
Southside, NY
Feb 7, 2024
Verified Review
Now showing 1-4 of 392 reviews for West Islip, NY
Private residential garages
Residential garages in West Islip average $519 with a minimum price of $249.
60% of garages have security cameras; average price with cameras is $404.
Quick responses: hosts reply within 6 hours on average, some in just 38 minutes.
Garage
20×10
Farmingdale, NY
6.5 mi
Near 610 Broad Hollow Rd
Climate Controlled
Private Entrance
$495
per month
Garage
20×20
East Northport, NY
9.4 mi
Near 15 Swarthmore Ln
Private Entrance
Locked Area
$550
per month
Garage
20×10
Paterson, NJ
46.8 mi
Near 380 E 29th St
5.0
Locked Area
Security Camera
50% off first month
$150
per month
Garage
20×10
Newark, NJ
48.3 mi
Near 95 W Allen St
5.0
Climate Controlled
Private Entrance
$129
per month
Parking garages
Parking Garage
20×10
Far Rockaway, NY
24.4 mi
1725 Village Ln Far Rockaway, New York
4.7
Instant book
Wheelchair Accessible
$149
per month
Parking Garage
18×9
New Rochelle, NY
28.5 mi
55 Clinton Pl New Rochelle, New York
4.7
Instant book
EV charging Available
Wheelchair Accessible
$125
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Teaneck, NJ
39.0 mi
Near 1 Norfolk St
5.0
Security Camera
No Stairs
$120
per month
Parking Garage
18×9
Scarsdale, NY
32.6 mi
2 Overhill Rd Scarsdale, New York
4.7
Instant book
Security Camera
EV charging Available
$150
per month
Closest spaces to my location
Average distance 9.1 miles, with the closest at 4.2 miles.
Average price $505, with garages ranging from $249 to $1000.
66% of listings are garages, and 50% have camera features.
Search your zip code:
- 11795
Public Storage: Self Storage Unit
25×10
Bethpage, NY
9.4 mi
4113 Hempstead Turnpike Bethpage, New York
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$507
per month
Public Storage: Self Storage Unit
30×10
Nesconset, NY
12.7 mi
770 Nesconset Hwy Nesconset, New York
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
$510
per month
Garage
20×10
Saint James, NY
13.9 mi
Near 237 7th St
Locked Area
Private Entrance
$365
per month
Public Storage: Self Storage Unit
20×10
Holbrook, NY
14.3 mi
15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, New York
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
starting at
$258
per month
Self storage in garages
75% of garage listings have security cameras; average price is $519.
Top Hosts present in 50% of garage listings; average distance is 13.4 miles.
Average garage size is 28 x 23 feet; average response time within 14.5 minutes.
Garage
20×10
Bridgeport, CT
32.7 mi
Near 20 Rutland Ave
5.0
Security Camera
Locked Area
50% off first month
$175
per month
Garage
20×10
Meriden, CT
64.0 mi
Near 455 Lewis Ave
Private Space
Locked Area
$94
per month
Top Host
Garage
20×8
Highland Falls, NY
56.8 mi
Near 48 Ondaora Pkwy
5.0
Private Entrance
Locked Area
50% off first month
$200
per month
Public Storage: Self Storage Unit
20×10
Farmingville, NY
17.2 mi
951 HorseBlock Road Farmingville, New York
Keyless Entry
Private Entrance
starting at
$303
per month
Cheap prices: Starting at $75
Average garage price $426, lowest $249. Sizes range 20-40 feet in length.
Carport: cheapest at $76, 4.2 miles away, has first month discount.
67% of garages have cameras, 50% offer first month discounts.
Parking Garage
22×8
Waterbury, CT
60.9 mi
Near 46 E Farm St
Security Camera
No Stairs
$85
per month
Carport
20×10
Hazlet, NJ
49.0 mi
Near 3 Larsen Ln
5.0
Private Space
50% off first month
$98
per month
Parking Lot
20×10
Sayreville, NJ
56.5 mi
Near 15 Wellington Ct
5.0
Instant book
50% off first month
$99
per month
Top Host
Parking Garage
20×10
Newburgh, NY
68.9 mi
Near 64 5th Ave
5.0
Security Camera
Electricity Available
50% off first month
$105
per month
Premium garages & services
Top Host
Parking Garage
20×10
Stamford, CT
26.3 mi
Near 37 Rose Park
5.0
Security Camera
Attendant or Security
50% off first month
$230
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
New York, NY
35.6 mi
50 W 44th St New York, New York
4.6
Instant book
Security Camera
Attendant or Security
$199
per month
Parking Garage
12×20
B, NY
31.5 mi
391 Weirfield St B, New York
5.0
Instant book
Attendant or Security
Electricity Available
$270
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Forest Hills, NY
27.9 mi
110-45 Queens Blvd Forest Hills, New York
3.4
Instant book
EV charging Available
Wheelchair Accessible
$275
per month
Top-rated garages for rent: 4+ star reviews
Parking Garage
20×10
Fresh Meadows, NY
25.5 mi
183-15 Horace Harding Expy Fresh Meadows, New York
4.9
Instant book
$500
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Jersey City, NJ
38.3 mi
455 Washington Blvd Jersey City, New Jersey
4.9
Instant book
$275
per month
Parking Garage
20×10
Southside, NY
34.1 mi
Near 122 Middleton St
5.0
Instant book
Climate Controlled
Private Entrance
$300
per month
Garage
20×18
Chester Township, NJ
74.9 mi
Near 16 State Park Rd
4.9
Private Entrance
Locked Area
$425
per month
How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities
Neighbor
Neighbor
Traditional facilities
Traditional facilities
Wide variety of sizes
Wide variety of sizes
Lowest prices
Lowest prices
Highest safety rating
Highest safety rating
Protection plans
Protection plans
Nationwide availability
Nationwide availability
Verified hosts
Verified hosts
Manage rental online
Manage rental online
Storage for Rent in West Islip, NY
Select storage type
What type of garage parking is best for you?
Private, residential garages and commercial parking garages both offer unique advantages. Explore which type is best for you below.
Indoor Residential Garages
Residential garages can provide maximum peace of mind at an affordable price.
Interested in increased privacy? 5% of garage listings in West Islip are listed as a private space
Enclosed Parking Garages
Commercial parking garages are available in urban areas for convenient access.
9% of storage spaces in West Islip have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host
Additional New York garages locations
Need garages in West Islip?
Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.
(844) 448-0805