Self storage units in New Buffalo, MI

Self storage units in New Buffalo, MI

4 locations available

Top Host

5×7 Warehouse in Michigan City, IN near 10750 Wilson Rd
5×7 Warehouse in Michigan City, IN near 10750 Wilson Rd 2
5×7 Warehouse in Michigan City, IN near 10750 Wilson Rd 3

Warehouse

5×7

Michigan City, IN

2.2 mi

Near 10750 Wilson Rd

5.0

7 months rented

50% off1st month

$49

per month

10×10 Basement in La Porte, IN near 4924 N County Road 400 W
10×10 Basement in La Porte, IN near 4924 N County Road 400 W 2
10×10 Basement in La Porte, IN near 4924 N County Road 400 W 3

Basement

10×10

La Porte, IN

9.1 mi

Near 4924 N County Road 400 W

50% off1st month

$40

per month

10×10 Storage space in La Porte, IN near 772 3rd St

Storage space

10×10

La Porte, IN

12.8 mi

Near 772 3rd St

50% off1st month

$39

per month

30×12 Garage in La Porte, IN near 2551 E County Road 100 S

Garage

30×12

La Porte, IN

14.4 mi

Near 2551 E County Road 100 S

5.0

21 months rented

"Highly recommend storing with Joshua. He has a large property with outdoor and indoor storage. I stored my pop-up camper outside for about 7 months. The camper was hidden from public view and easy to access to move. He is very responsive and kept an eye on my camper when there were storms. It was very helpful to store my camper there while I was in transition moving between states. Thanks a ton!"- Verified review

50% off1st month

$89

per month

See all 4 storage options in New Buffalo

Neighbor reviews near New Buffalo, Michigan

4.9 (337 reviews)

Based on 337 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in New Buffalo 4.9 out of 5 on average

K

Kathleen D.

-

Crown Point, IN

Aug 22, 2024

Verified Review

profile

Jessica C.

-

Mishawaka, IN

Oct 13, 2023

Verified Review

T

Timothy S.

-

Edwardsburg, MI

Sep 25, 2023

Verified Review

E

Esther L.

-

Decatur, MI

Sep 13, 2023

Verified Review

M

Michelle K.

-

Chicago, IL

Feb 5, 2024

Verified Review

T

Tony C.

-

Decatur, MI

May 25, 2024

Verified Review

Now showing 1-6 of 337 reviews for New Buffalo, MI

Closest units to my location
  • Find self storage closest to you. You could find storage within a few blocks.

  • Search your zip code:

    • 49117

Not affiliated with Neighbor

BinTris Moving and Self Storage - New Buffalo in New Buffalo, MI

BinTris Moving and Self Storage - New Buffalo

New Buffalo, MI

0.9 mi

901 E Buffalo St New Buffalo, MI

5.0

starting at

$46

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Harbor Country Storage in New Buffalo, MI

Harbor Country Storage

New Buffalo, MI

1.0 mi

18555 La Porte Rd New Buffalo, MI

4.8

Pros: very clean and safe facility, reasonably priced storage units, helpful and attentive management, good security with cameras and gate

starting at

$89

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Hearthfire Self Storage in La Porte, IN

Hearthfire Self Storage

La Porte, IN

3.0 mi

9845 N Old Buffalo Rd La Porte, IN

4.5

Pros: numerous updates and issue fixes, easy payment and access, convenient short-notice setup for parking

starting at

$53

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Harbor Country Storage in Three Oaks, MI

Harbor Country Storage

Three Oaks, MI

4.6 mi

7301 US-12 Three Oaks, MI

4.5

Pros: affordable storage rental, clean and neat facility

starting at

$89

per month

View all listings

Cheap prices: Starting at $39
  • Find a space or unit that can store your personal items at a cheap cost. Save 33%, on average, by booking with Neighbor compared to traditional storage facilities.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Store-More Mini Warehouse in New Carlisle, IN

Store-More Mini Warehouse

New Carlisle, IN

11.5 mi

8830 E 700 N New Carlisle, IN

4.8

Pros: wide variety of unit sizes., clean and well-maintained facility., 24-hour security with gated entry., fair and reasonable pricing., well-lit and maintained environment.

starting at

$75

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Store More Mini Warehouses in New Carlisle, IN

Store More Mini Warehouses

New Carlisle, IN

11.7 mi

8886 US-20 New Carlisle, IN

starting at

$75

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

AIM Storage in La Porte, IN

AIM Storage

La Porte, IN

10.4 mi

2467 N State Road 39 La Porte, IN

4.4

Pros: offers units with 24 hour accessCons: monthly rates have increased by $20, gate has never functioned properly, security buildings allegedly unsafe

starting at

$85

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Hearthfire Self Storage La Porte on Detroit St in La Porte, IN

Hearthfire Self Storage La Porte on Detroit St

La Porte, IN

12.2 mi

406 Detroit St La Porte, IN

Pros: units seem clean and secure, quick resolution for insurance claims, good investment for peace of mindCons: gate and code box frequently broken, late and hidden fees charged, difficult to access due to construction, prorated payments not offered, constant and unexplained rate increases

starting at

$130

per month

View all listings

Larger units: 10x15 and above
  • Find large self storage spaces that can fit several items like furniture, beds, TVs, etc. All in a single unit.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Storage Rentals of America in Michigan City, IN

Storage Rentals of America

Michigan City, IN

7.8 mi

101 Lumber Center Rd Michigan City, IN

4.2

Pros: professional and polite customer service, quick and easy process, good access and convenient locationCons: frequent and high rate increases, harsh policies on late payments, facilities nearby are much cheaper

starting at

$144

per month

View all listings

Smaller units: 5x5 and below
  • Find self storage spaces that can fit most items in a bedroom or closet. New Buffalo spaces on Neighbor are 16% less expensive, on average, than traditional storage facilities.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Mini Storage Depot in Michigan City, IN

Mini Storage Depot

Michigan City, IN

11.1 mi

951 E US Highway 20 Michigan City, IN

4.3

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, friendly and helpful staff, secure storage with surveillanceCons: reports of water and rodent damage, some units have had snake infestations

starting at

$89

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

BinTris Moving and Self Storage - Bridgman in Bridgman, MI

BinTris Moving and Self Storage - Bridgman

Bridgman, MI

14.5 mi

8677 Red Arrow Hwy Bridgman, MI

4.0

Pros: clean and secure facility, nice and helpful office staffCons: unprofessional handling of security issues, missed appointments and late arrivals, poor response to customer concerns, rodent infestations in some units

starting at

$48

per month

View all listings

Drive-up access with your vehicle
  • Find spaces where you can drive up to load and unload items from a vehicle or truck.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Infinite Self Storage - La Porte in La Porte, IN

Infinite Self Storage - La Porte

La Porte, IN

13.9 mi

1310 W 18th St La Porte, IN

3.0

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, friendly and courteous staff, convenient location, 24/7 service availabilityCons: multiple reports of break-ins and theft, reports of unresponsive customer service, significant issues with security (holes in fence, no cameras), constant billing and insurance issues after fire, price increases and high rates

starting at

$51

per month

View all listings

Find nearby storage locations

Michigan City, Indiana (10 mi)
La Porte, Indiana (13 mi)
Chesterton, Indiana (22 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

Storage facility cost comparison

5×5

5×10

10×10

10×20

10×30

10×40

Average storage facility

New Buffalo, MI

$61

$67

$95

$126

$160

$177

Neighbor

4 storage spaces nearby

BinTris Moving and Self Storage

New Buffalo, MI (1 miles)

$65

$80

$178

$223

--

--

Harbor Country Storage

New Buffalo, MI (1 miles)

$89

$109

$169

$269

$314

--

Hearthfire Self Storage

La Porte, IN (3 miles)

$53

$53

$53

$53

$53

--

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units
open view of an empty garage

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

69% of storage spaces in New Buffalo have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

Find drive-up storage
Interior-Access Storage Units
row of indoor storage lockers

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

In New Buffalo, 91% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

Find indoor storage units
Vehicle Storage Units
view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in New Buffalo is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

Find car storage units

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near New Buffalo

Although traditional storage facilities are available in New Buffalo, Michigan, Neighbor storage features cheap, close by and secure self storage.

If you'd like information about traditional self storage nearby, look at the list of facilities for more information:

Hearthfire Self Storage (3 miles)

9845 N Old Buffalo Rd La Porte, IN

BinTris Moving and Self Storage - New Buffalo (0.9 miles)

901 E Buffalo St New Buffalo, MI

Storage Rentals of America (7.8 miles)

101 Lumber Center Rd Michigan City, IN

AIM Storage (10.4 miles)

2467 N State Road 39 La Porte, IN

Bigger Garage Self-Storage (19 miles)

5981 S State Road 39 La Porte, IN

Store-More Mini Warehouse (11.5 miles)

8830 E 700 N New Carlisle, IN

Harbor Country Storage (1 miles)

18555 La Porte Rd New Buffalo, MI

Storage Of America (24.7 miles)

1515 Townline Rd Benton Harbor, MI

Harbor Country Storage (4.6 miles)

7301 US-12 Three Oaks, MI

Storage City (20 miles)

4465 Red Arrow Hwy Stevensville, MI

Hearthfire Self Storage La Porte on Detroit St (12.2 miles)

406 Detroit St La Porte, IN

Mini Storage Depot (11.1 miles)

951 E US Highway 20 Michigan City, IN

BinTris Moving and Self Storage - Stevensville (16.5 miles)

7197 Red Arrow Hwy Stevensville, MI

Store More Mini Warehouses (11.7 miles)

8886 US-20 New Carlisle, IN

6 & 49 Storage (23.5 miles)

137 E US Highway 6 Valparaiso, IN

Need self storage in New Buffalo?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 448-0855