Self storage units in Bay Shore, NY

Self storage units in Bay Shore, NY

57 locations available

20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Bay Shore, NY 122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, New York
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Bay Shore, NY 122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, New York 2
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Bay Shore, NY 122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, New York 3

Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

20×10

Bay Shore, NY

1.0 mi

122 Saxon Ave Bay Shore, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

"The vibe at the place is great, and the customer service is top-notch."- Verified review

2nd monthFREE

starting at

$312

per month

20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in West Babylon, NY 821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in West Babylon, NY 821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York 2
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in West Babylon, NY 821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York 3

Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

20×10

West Babylon, NY

4.8 mi

821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

"They had almost every size you could think of."- Verified review

starting at

$370

per month

20×10 Attic in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr
20×10 Attic in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 2
20×10 Attic in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 3

Attic

20×10

Melville, NY

9.3 mi

Near Bioscience Park Dr

5.0

11 months rented

$125

per month

12×8 Bedroom in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr
12×8 Bedroom in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 2
12×8 Bedroom in Melville, NY near Bioscience Park Dr 3

Bedroom

12×8

Melville, NY

9.3 mi

Near Bioscience Park Dr

5.0

11 months rented

$125

per month

7×7 Closet in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 1504 RT-112
7×7 Closet in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 1504 RT-112 2
7×7 Closet in Port Jefferson Station, NY near 1504 RT-112 3

Closet

7×7

Port Jefferson Station, NY

17.3 mi

Near 1504 RT-112

$40

per month

20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Commack, NY 5052 Jericho Turnpike Commack, New York
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Commack, NY 5052 Jericho Turnpike Commack, New York 2
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Commack, NY 5052 Jericho Turnpike Commack, New York 3

Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

20×10

Commack, NY

8.3 mi

5052 Jericho Turnpike Commack, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

"I had a really great experience with Danielle at the Commack location."- Verified review

$318

per month

9×9 Bedroom in Bayport, NY near 1598 Lakeview Ave

Bedroom

9×9

Bayport, NY

10.4 mi

Near 1598 Lakeview Ave

50% off1st month

starting at

$54

per month

20×7 Attic in Lindenhurst, NY near 137 Inlet Dr
20×7 Attic in Lindenhurst, NY near 137 Inlet Dr 2
20×7 Attic in Lindenhurst, NY near 137 Inlet Dr 3

Attic

20×7

Lindenhurst, NY

7.5 mi

Near 137 Inlet Dr

50% off1st month

$95

per month

30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Nesconset, NY 72 Southern Blvd Nesconset, New York
30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Nesconset, NY 72 Southern Blvd Nesconset, New York 2
30×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Nesconset, NY 72 Southern Blvd Nesconset, New York 3

Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

30×10

Nesconset, NY

9.6 mi

72 Southern Blvd Nesconset, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

2nd monthFREE

$278

per month

20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Farmingdale, NY 47 Broadhollow Road Farmingdale, New York
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Farmingdale, NY 47 Broadhollow Road Farmingdale, New York 2
20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Farmingdale, NY 47 Broadhollow Road Farmingdale, New York 3

Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

20×10

Farmingdale, NY

9.6 mi

47 Broadhollow Road Farmingdale, New York

4.9

200+ months rented

2nd monthFREE

$312

per month

20×10 Garage in East Patchogue, NY near 12 Beatrice Ct
20×10 Garage in East Patchogue, NY near 12 Beatrice Ct 2
20×10 Garage in East Patchogue, NY near 12 Beatrice Ct 3

Garage

20×10

East Patchogue, NY

13.4 mi

Near 12 Beatrice Ct

5.0

45 months rented

$110

per month

20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in Holbrook, NY 15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, New York

Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

20×10

Holbrook, NY

10.8 mi

15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, New York

5.0

200+ months rented

$1first month

starting at

$258

per month

10×10 Warehouse in Ronkonkoma, NY near 28 17th Ave

Warehouse

10×10

Ronkonkoma, NY

7.3 mi

Near 28 17th Ave

$95

per month

20×20 Garage in Babylon, NY near 457 Great East Neck Rd
20×20 Garage in Babylon, NY near 457 Great East Neck Rd 2
20×20 Garage in Babylon, NY near 457 Great East Neck Rd 3

Garage

20×20

Babylon, NY

5.4 mi

Near 457 Great East Neck Rd

4.0

3 months rented

Perfect solution for secure and spacious storage.

50% off1st month

$900

per month

30×10 Garage in West Babylon, NY near August Rd
30×10 Garage in West Babylon, NY near August Rd 2
30×10 Garage in West Babylon, NY near August Rd 3

Garage

30×10

West Babylon, NY

5.3 mi

Near August Rd

50% off1st month

$215

per month

See all 57 storage options in Bay Shore

Neighbor reviews near Bay Shore, NY

5.0 (8,212 reviews)

Based on 8,212 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in Bay Shore 5.0 out of 5 on average

Closest units to my location
  • Search your zip code:

    • 11706

Not affiliated with Neighbor

CubeSmart Self Storage in Brightwaters, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage

Brightwaters, NY

1.0 mi

59 Orinoco Dr Brightwaters, NY

4.8

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility., convenient location with easy access., helpful and friendly staff., temperature-controlled units available.Cons: high prices for storage units., mold reported on some stored items after long-term storage., difficulty with upper-level unit access.

starting at

$75

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Prime Storage in Bay Shore, NY

Prime Storage

Bay Shore, NY

3.3 mi

99 Pine Aire Dr Bay Shore, NY

4.1

Pros: great customer service from staff, clean and accessible storage units, competitive and good pricing, convenient and easy locationCons: price increases occur annually, untimely rent hikes noted by customers

starting at

$89

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

CubeSmart Self Storage in North Babylon, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage

North Babylon, NY

3.8 mi

240 Bay Shore Rd North Babylon, NY

4.8

Pros: friendly and helpful staff, clean and well-maintained facility, easy and smooth check-in process, reasonable and knowledgeable customer serviceCons: units prone to mold and water damage, presence of rat feces and traps, significant rent increases over time, charges full month despite early move-out

starting at

$48

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Extra Space Storage in North Babylon, NY

Extra Space Storage

North Babylon, NY

3.8 mi

1251 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY

5.0

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, polite and professional staff, rental process is quick and easy, secure buildingCons: facility ownership changes frequently, difficult to reach customer service, frequent and significant price increases, complicated procedures due to office closures

starting at

$78

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Premier Storage Solutions of West Islip in West Islip, NY

Premier Storage Solutions of West Islip

West Islip, NY

3.9 mi

175 Union Blvd West Islip, NY

4.2

Pros: very secure with keypad access, open 24 hours for convenient entry, well-maintained and clean facility, useful carts always available

starting at

$115

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

CubeSmart Self Storage in Deer Park, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage

Deer Park, NY

4.4 mi

999 Long Island Ave Deer Park, NY

4.6

Pros: clean and well-lit facility, easy sign-up and reservation process, friendly and helpful staffCons: rents increase every six to seven months, lack of proper security measures, office often closed during business hours, price considered too high by some users

starting at

$77

per month

20×10 Public Storage: Self Storage Unit in West Babylon, NY

Public Storage: Self Storage Unit

20×10

West Babylon, NY

4.8 mi

821 Sunrise Hwy West Babylon, New York

5.0

Pet Free

No Stairs

"This place is super clean !!"- Verified review

starting at

$370

per month

30×10 Garage in West Babylon, NY

Garage

30×10

West Babylon, NY

5.3 mi

Near August Rd

Private Space

Private Entrance

50% off first month

$215

per month

20×20 Garage in Babylon, NY

Garage

20×20

Babylon, NY

5.4 mi

Near 457 Great East Neck Rd

4.0

Smoke Detectors

Private Entrance

50% off first month

$900

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Metro Self Storage - Oakdale in Oakdale, NY

Metro Self Storage - Oakdale

Oakdale, NY

5.7 mi

4038 Sunrise Hwy Oakdale, NY

4.4

Pros: clean and well-maintained facility, reasonable and stable pricing, quick and efficient service, easy and local accessCons: online payment issues unresolved, terrible experience with climate control maintenance, private information divulgence recurring, break-ins and poor on-site supervision, unpragmatic desking inhibiting first impressions

starting at

$48

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Extra Space Storage in Deer Park, NY

Extra Space Storage

Deer Park, NY

5.6 mi

541 Acorn St Deer Park, NY

Pros: great customer service experience, facility is very clean, easy to sign up online, helpful and kind staff

starting at

$80

per month

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

Storage for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

Select storage type

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units
open view of an empty garage

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

None of the currently available storage spaces in Bay Shore have security cameras as an amenity

Interior-Access Storage Units
row of indoor storage lockers

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

In Bay Shore, 100% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

Vehicle Storage Units
view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in Bay Shore is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

Additional New York self storage locations

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Bay Shore

Even though Neighbor has the lower-priced, more secure, and nearest self storage, storage facilities could also be a potential option for self storage in Bay Shore, NY.

Look at the list of self storage facilities for details:

CubeSmart Self Storage (3.8 miles)

240 Bay Shore Rd North Babylon, NY

Metro Self Storage - Oakdale (5.7 miles)

4038 Sunrise Hwy Oakdale, NY

Extra Space Storage (8.5 miles)

510 Johnson Ave Bohemia, NY

Public Storage (11.1 miles)

601 Sunrise Hwy Patchogue, NY

Extra Space Storage (3.8 miles)

1251 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY

Prime Storage (3.3 miles)

99 Pine Aire Dr Bay Shore, NY

Prime Storage (8.8 miles)

868 Lincoln Ave Bohemia, NY

CubeSmart Self Storage (1 miles)

59 Orinoco Dr Brightwaters, NY

Cubesmart Self Storage (11.8 miles)

120 River Ave Patchogue, NY

Extra Space Storage (11.9 miles)

970 Waverly Ave Holtsville, NY

Public Storage (8.3 miles)

5052 Jericho Tpke Commack, NY

iStorage Self Storage (11.8 miles)

257 Waverly Ave Patchogue, NY

Extra Space Storage (12.5 miles)

151 Sunnyside Blvd Plainview, NY

Extra Space Storage (9.8 miles)

281 Indian Head Rd Kings Park, NY

Safeguard Self Storage (11.3 miles)

1522 Old Country Rd Plainview, NY

Need self storage in Bay Shore?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 448-0855