Self storage units in East Setauket, NY

Recommended

Best price, quality and distance

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

73 spaces near East Setauket

Closet

7’ × 7’

Port Jefferson Station, NY

3.1 mi

near 1504 RT-112

Private Space

Pet Free

No Stairs

Locked Area

$49/ mo

Garage

20’ × 20’

Setauket- East Setauket, NY

0.9 mi

near 54 N Belle Mead Rd

Pet Free

No Stairs

Smoke Free

Private Space

Locked Area

$249/ mo

Attic

24’ × 11’

Centereach, NY

2.7 mi

near 93 Forest Rd

Smoke Free

Private Entrance

Locked Area

It is smoke-free.

$150/ mo

Average distance is 2.6 miles; 25% of listings within 1.6 miles.
50% of listings have climate control and elevators; prices range $18-$787.
Fastest response time: 21 minutes; average host response is 24 hours.

Public Storage

7 sizes available

4.8

225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, NY

1.6 mi

similarly priced

Pros:

Staff provides excellent service
Facility is clean and maintains well

Cons:

Severe mold issue in units
Poor air quality and pest problems
Limited staff availability affects service

5'×5'

starting at

$57/ mo

5'×7'

starting at

$62/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$90/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

$134/ mo

10'×8'

starting at

$137/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$156/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$309/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$57

Prime Storage

16 sizes available

4.3

1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson Station, NY

2.7 mi

47% more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-maintained facility
Very secure with security measures
Friendly and helpful staff
Convenient location and accessible units

Cons:

Frequent and significant price increases
Some units not the advertised size
Difficulties with online payment processing
Inconsistent promotion and discount policies

4'×5'

starting at

$69/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

$108/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

$98/ mo

5'×8'

starting at

$132/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$155/ mo

10'×6'

starting at

$173/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$254/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

$267/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$382/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$444/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$521/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

$642/ mo

10'×32'

starting at

$666/ mo

12'×20'

starting at

$242/ mo

12'×40'

starting at

$292/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$198/ mo

4'×5' starting at

$69

Extra Space Storage

8 sizes available

4.8

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

4.6 mi

70% more expensive

Pros:

Units are clean and well-maintained.
Location is safe and secure.
Helpful and friendly staff.
Conveniently located with a variety of unit sizes.

Cons:

Website and online process can be confusing.
High curbs at some units.
Some units smaller than listed dimensions.

4'×4'

starting at

$35/ mo

4'×8'

starting at

$60/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

$50/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$153/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$269/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$339/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$312/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$150/ mo

4'×4' starting at

$35

Find nearby storage locations

Port Jefferson Station, New York (2 mi)

Stony Brook, New York (2 mi)

Terryville, New York (2 mi)

Port Jefferson, New York (3 mi)

Centereach, New York (3 mi)

Selden, New York (4 mi)

Lake Grove, New York (4 mi)

Mount Sinai, New York (4 mi)

Coram, New York (5 mi)

Miller Place, New York (5 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage facility cost comparison

	10×20	10×40
Average storage facility East Setauket, NY	$347	$271
Neighbor 27 storage spaces nearby	$150	$249
Public Storage Port Jefferson, NY (2 miles)	--	--
Prime Storage Port Jefferson Station, NY (3 miles)	$242	$292
Extra Space Storage Coram, NY (5 miles)	$312	--

Storage for Rent in East Setauket, NY

Select storage type

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

None of the currently available storage spaces in East Setauket have security cameras as an amenity

Find drive-up storage

Interior-Access Storage Units

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

In East Setauket, 50% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

Find indoor storage units

Vehicle Storage Units

view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in East Setauket is 65% more expensive than nearby areas

Find car storage units

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near East Setauket

While traditional storage facilities are commonly available in East Setauket, New York, Neighbor.com usually has the more cost-effective, safest, and closest self storage.

Check out the facilities below for information:

Public Storage (1.6 miles)

225 Sheep Pasture Rd Port Jefferson, NY

Extra Space Storage (9 miles)

1960 Veterans Memorial Hwy Islandia, NY

Public Storage (5 miles)

550 Middle Country Rd Coram, NY

Extra Space Storage (8.8 miles)

3016 Express Dr S Islandia, NY

Extra Space Storage (4.6 miles)

2025 Route 112 Coram, NY

Bayport Mini Storage (11.5 miles)