Self storage units in St. James, NY

Recommended

Best price, quality and distance

Closest to me

Enter your zip for nearby units

Cheap prices

Storage units as low as $111/mo

Large units

Large bedroom size; 10x15 & up

19 spaces near St. James

Closet

7’ × 7’

Port Jefferson Station, NY

7.9 mi

near 1504 RT-112

Private Space

Pet Free

No Stairs

Locked Area

$49/ mo

Attic

24’ × 11’

Centereach, NY

3.8 mi

near 93 Forest Rd

Smoke Free

Private Entrance

Locked Area

$150/ mo

Warehouse

10’ × 10’

Ronkonkoma, NY

4.4 mi

near 28 17th Ave

Private Entrance

Pet Free

Security Camera

No Stairs

Smoke Free

$139/ mo

Find self storage closest to you. You could find storage within a few blocks.

Garage

20’ × 20’

Setauket- East Setauket, NY

4.5 mi

near 54 N Belle Mead Rd

Pet Free

No Stairs

Smoke Free

Private Space

Locked Area

$249/ mo

extraspace.com

Extra Space Storage

6 sizes available

4.9

281 Indian Head Rd Kings Park, NY

5.2 mi

80% more expensive

Pros:

Helpful and friendly staff
Clean and well-maintained units

Cons:

Significant rent increases after a short time
Online signup can lead to duplicate charges

5'×5'

starting at

$97/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$159/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$348/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$537/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$537/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$335/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$97

publicst...rage.com

Simply Self Storage

5 sizes available

745 Old Willets Path Hauppauge, NY

5.2 mi

58% more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-maintained premises
Excellent and helpful staff
Secure facility with multiple security codes
Close to residential areas

Cons:

Frequent rate increases
Rates can double within a year
Acquired by a less favorable company

5'×5'

starting at

$99/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$143/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$270/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$365/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$357/ mo

5'×5' starting at

$99

Find a space or unit that can store your personal items at a cheap cost. Save 19%, on average, by booking with Neighbor compared to traditional storage facilities.

storquest.com

StorQuest Self Storage

17 sizes available

4.4

960 Grand Blvd Deer Park, NY

10 mi

55% more expensive

Pros:

Very clean and brightly lit
Staff is friendly and helpful
Prices are reasonable industry-wide
Easy access for loading/unloading

Cons:

High parking lot rental cost
Closed on Sundays

4'×5'

starting at

$33/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

$64/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

$49/ mo

5'×8'

starting at

$111/ mo

5'×9'

starting at

$72/ mo

9'×26'

starting at

$176/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$111/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

$163/ mo

10'×9'

starting at

$179/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$280/ mo

10'×11'

starting at

$241/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$339/ mo

10'×18'

starting at

$644/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$423/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$844/ mo

11'×13'

starting at

$345/ mo

20'×9'

starting at

$168/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$111

devonsel...rage.com

Extra Space Storage

10 sizes available

4.9

84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

11.5 mi

51% more expensive

Pros:

Facility is clean and well maintained
Safe and secure environment
Climate-controlled storage options available

5'×5'

starting at

$54/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$113/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

$197/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$187/ mo

10'×14'

starting at

$178/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$302/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$406/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$458/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

$529/ mo

15'×15'

starting at

$506/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$113

publicst...rage.com

Public Storage

7 sizes available

4.6

15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, NY

8.1 mi

54% more expensive

Pros:

Facility generally well maintained and clean
Helpful and friendly staff
Quick and efficient rental process

Cons:

High late fee charges
Issues with security doors and access codes
Infrequent staffing at front desk
Unpleasant customer service experiences
Unexpected substantial price increases

5'×5'

starting at

$81/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$127/ mo

10'×7'

starting at

$159/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$244/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$301/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$417/ mo

10'×27'

starting at

$529/ mo

10'×5' starting at

$127

Find large self storage spaces that can fit several items like furniture, beds, TVs, etc. All in a single unit. Neighbor offers large self storage in St. James up to 23% cheaper than traditional storage facilities.

Storage space

83’ × 65’

Commack, NY

6.1 mi

near 19 Cameo Rd

Private Entrance

$1,458/ mo

primesto...roup.com

Prime Storage

16 sizes available

4.3

1184 Route 112 Port Jefferson Station, NY

7.5 mi

48% more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-maintained facility
Very secure with security measures
Friendly and helpful staff
Convenient location and accessible units

Cons:

Frequent and significant price increases
Some units not the advertised size
Difficulties with online payment processing
Inconsistent promotion and discount policies

4'×5'

starting at

$69/ mo

5'×5'

starting at

$108/ mo

5'×6'

starting at

$98/ mo

5'×8'

starting at

$132/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$155/ mo

10'×6'

starting at

$173/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$254/ mo

10'×12'

starting at

$267/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$382/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$444/ mo

10'×25'

starting at

$521/ mo

10'×30'

starting at

$642/ mo

10'×32'

starting at

$666/ mo

12'×20'

starting at

$242/ mo

12'×40'

starting at

$292/ mo

15'×5'

starting at

$198/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$382

lifestorage.com

Extra Space Storage

7 sizes available

5.0

1251 Deer Park Ave North Babylon, NY

11.7 mi

86% more expensive

Pros:

Clean and well-maintained facility
Polite and professional staff
Rental process is quick and easy
Secure building

Cons:

Facility ownership changes frequently
Difficult to reach customer service
Frequent and significant price increases
Complicated procedures due to office closures

5'×5'

starting at

$89/ mo

5'×8'

starting at

$110/ mo

10'×5'

starting at

$147/ mo

10'×10'

starting at

$338/ mo

10'×15'

starting at

$361/ mo

10'×20'

starting at

$602/ mo

12'×5'

starting at

$145/ mo

10'×15' starting at

$361

Find nearby storage locations

Nesconset, New York (1 mi)

Lake Grove, New York (2 mi)

Lake Ronkonkoma, New York (3 mi)

Smithtown, New York (3 mi)

Hauppauge, New York (4 mi)

Stony Brook, New York (4 mi)

Centereach, New York (4 mi)

Ronkonkoma, New York (4 mi)

Kings Park, New York (5 mi)

Central Islip, New York (5 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

View reviews for Neighbor

Storage facility cost comparison

	5×5	5×10	10×10	10×20	10×30
Average storage facility St. James, NY	$77	$132	$215	$368	$455
Neighbor 6 storage spaces nearby	$70	$135	$149	$240	$351
Extra Space Storage Kings Park, NY (5 miles)	$97	$159	$348	$537	--
Simply Self Storage Hauppauge, NY (5 miles)	$99	$143	$270	$357	--
Prime Storage Port Jefferson Station, NY (8 miles)	$98	$155	$242	$242	$292

Storage for Rent in St. James, NY

Select storage type

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

59% of storage spaces in St. James have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

Find drive-up storage

Interior-Access Storage Units

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

In St. James, 50% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

Find indoor storage units

Vehicle Storage Units

view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in St. James is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

Find car storage units

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near St. James

St. James offers many different traditional self storage options for self storage. Traditional self storage, however, are often pricier, less secure, and typically farther way than peer-to-peer storage.

If you'd like information about traditional self storage in St. James, see the list of facilities for more information:

Extra Space Storage (11.5 miles)

84 Long Island Ave Yaphank, NY

iStorage Self Storage (8.7 miles)

709 Church St Bayport, NY

Extra Space Storage (5.2 miles)

281 Indian Head Rd Kings Park, NY

Public Storage (8.1 miles)

15 Andrea Rd Holbrook, NY

StorQuest Self Storage (10 miles)

960 Grand Blvd Deer Park, NY

Prime Storage (7.5 miles)