Self storage units in Whitefish Bay, WI

Self storage units in Whitefish Bay, WI

18 locations available

8×6 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 3870 S 55th St
8×6 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 3870 S 55th St 2
8×6 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 3870 S 55th St 3

Garage

8×6

Milwaukee, WI

8.6 mi

Near 3870 S 55th St

4.7

56 months rented

$25

per month

10×10 Basement in Milwaukee, WI near 2864 N Cramer St
10×10 Basement in Milwaukee, WI near 2864 N Cramer St 2

Basement

10×10

Milwaukee, WI

1.7 mi

Near 2864 N Cramer St

4.0

50 months rented

Flexible lease dates can be month to month or an entire year.

$49

per month

9×6 Attic in Milwaukee, WI near 5345 N 55th St
9×6 Attic in Milwaukee, WI near 5345 N 55th St 2
9×6 Attic in Milwaukee, WI near 5345 N 55th St 3

Attic

9×6

Milwaukee, WI

3.9 mi

Near 5345 N 55th St

50% off1st month

$35

per month

13×8 Basement in Fox Point, WI near 8447 N Indian Creek Pkwy
13×8 Basement in Fox Point, WI near 8447 N Indian Creek Pkwy 2
13×8 Basement in Fox Point, WI near 8447 N Indian Creek Pkwy 3

Basement

13×8

Fox Point, WI

5.1 mi

Near 8447 N Indian Creek Pkwy

We have a clean unfinished basement with lots of room for storage.

50% off1st month

$49

per month

20×10 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 3525 N 21st St
20×10 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 3525 N 21st St 2
20×10 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 3525 N 21st St 3

Garage

20×10

Milwaukee, WI

2.5 mi

Near 3525 N 21st St

9 months rented

$107

per month

20×20 Basement in Milwaukee, WI near 1707 W Reynolds Pl
20×20 Basement in Milwaukee, WI near 1707 W Reynolds Pl 2
20×20 Basement in Milwaukee, WI near 1707 W Reynolds Pl 3

Basement

20×20

Milwaukee, WI

5.1 mi

Near 1707 W Reynolds Pl

I have a huge basement available.

$89

per month

20×20 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 8027 W Gertrude Dr
20×20 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 8027 W Gertrude Dr 2
20×20 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 8027 W Gertrude Dr 3

Garage

20×20

Milwaukee, WI

5.2 mi

Near 8027 W Gertrude Dr

50% off1st month

$89

per month

16×20 Garage in Milwaukee, WI near 4737 W Sumac Pl

Garage

16×20

Milwaukee, WI

7.7 mi

Near 4737 W Sumac Pl

4.7

56 months rented

$74

per month

14×10 Garage in West Allis, WI near 2075 S 114th St

Garage

14×10

West Allis, WI

9.1 mi

Near 2075 S 114th St

4.0

3 months rented

50% off1st month

$90

per month

10×8 Bedroom in Milwaukee, WI near 7921 W Tripoli Ave
10×8 Bedroom in Milwaukee, WI near 7921 W Tripoli Ave 2
10×8 Bedroom in Milwaukee, WI near 7921 W Tripoli Ave 3

Bedroom

10×8

Milwaukee, WI

9.1 mi

Near 7921 W Tripoli Ave

5.0

18 months rented

My home is in the Wedgewood Park subdivision.

50% off1st month

starting at

$60

per month

10×10 Basement in West Allis, WI near 3236 S 121st St
10×10 Basement in West Allis, WI near 3236 S 121st St 2

Basement

10×10

West Allis, WI

10.9 mi

Near 3236 S 121st St

This space is complete with security cameras and smoke detectors for added safety.

$52

per month

30×10 Garage in New Berlin, WI near 12665 W Bobwood Rd
30×10 Garage in New Berlin, WI near 12665 W Bobwood Rd 2
30×10 Garage in New Berlin, WI near 12665 W Bobwood Rd 3

Garage

30×10

New Berlin, WI

12.4 mi

Near 12665 W Bobwood Rd

50% off1st month

$119

per month

7×5 Self Storage Unit in Waukesha, WI 1701 Airport Rd Waukesha, Wisconsin
7×5 Self Storage Unit in Waukesha, WI 1701 Airport Rd Waukesha, Wisconsin 2
7×5 Self Storage Unit in Waukesha, WI 1701 Airport Rd Waukesha, Wisconsin 3

Self Storage Unit

7×5

Waukesha, WI

16.9 mi

1701 Airport Rd Waukesha, Wisconsin

We'll take inventory of items as they are moved into the vault.

$75

per month

100×17 Self Storage Unit in Mequon, WI 10930 N Port Washington Rd Mequon, Wisconsin
100×17 Self Storage Unit in Mequon, WI 10930 N Port Washington Rd Mequon, Wisconsin 2
100×17 Self Storage Unit in Mequon, WI 10930 N Port Washington Rd Mequon, Wisconsin 3

Self Storage Unit

100×17

Mequon, WI

8.7 mi

10930 N Port Washington Rd Mequon, Wisconsin

Instant book

Storage unit available in Mequon!

$1,955

per month

300×100 Warehouse in Milwaukee, WI near 5909 W Blue Mound Rd
300×100 Warehouse in Milwaukee, WI near 5909 W Blue Mound Rd 2
300×100 Warehouse in Milwaukee, WI near 5909 W Blue Mound Rd 3

Warehouse

300×100

Milwaukee, WI

6.2 mi

Near 5909 W Blue Mound Rd

5.0

60 months rented

Great 3,000-square-foot warehouse space located in Milwaukee, WI.

$2,730

per month

See all 18 storage options in Whitefish Bay

Neighbor reviews near Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin

4.9 (162 reviews)

Based on 162 verified reviews, renters rated Neighbor's service for finding self storage units in Whitefish Bay 4.9 out of 5 on average

D

Derick E.

-

West Allis, WI

Aug 31, 2024

Verified Review

S

Shane S.

-

Milwaukee, WI

Jun 27, 2023

Verified Review

H

Helen H.

-

Milwaukee, WI

Apr 1, 2024

Verified Review

K

Kevin T.

-

Hartland, WI

Oct 4, 2024

Verified Review

J

John G.

-

New Berlin, WI

Apr 29, 2023

Verified Review

D

Dan M.

-

Mukwonago, WI

Nov 2, 2022

Verified Review

Now showing 1-6 of 162 reviews for Whitefish Bay, WI

Closest units to my location
  • Average storage unit price within 0.3 miles: $188. Climate-controlled features in 75% of units.

  • Within 0.5 miles, average host response time: 45 minutes. 100% access by appointment.

  • Largest garage space: 30x50 feet, 1.2 miles away. 25% offer indoor exposure.

  • Search your zip code:

    • 53217
    • 53211

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Store Here Self Storage in Milwaukee, WI

Store Here Self Storage

Milwaukee, WI

0.2 mi

4300 N Richards St Milwaukee, WI

4.8

Pros: friendly and professional customer service, secure facility with attentive staff, clean and well-maintained location, reasonable prices and good dealsCons: frequent rent increases concern customers, broken doors compromise security, unclean and locked bathrooms, company lacks effective response to complaints

starting at

$39

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Life Storage in Milwaukee, WI

Life Storage

Milwaukee, WI

1.3 mi

4565 N Green Bay Ave Milwaukee, WI

4.8

Pros: fast and efficient customer service, a few friendly and helpful staff, relatively easy reservation processCons: frequent and significant price increases, poor security—broken garage doors, cleanliness issues and non-functional restrooms, problems with reservation and refunds, reports of mice and insect infestations

starting at

$36

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Humboldt Storage in Milwaukee, WI

Humboldt Storage

Milwaukee, WI

1.4 mi

1001 E Chambers St Milwaukee, WI

4.0

Pros: security cameras throughout the facility, nice lighting during the nightCons: units sometimes unavailable after reservation, gate locked without advance notice, poor customer service responsiveness

starting at

$155

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

SmartStop Self Storage - Milwaukee in Milwaukee, WI

SmartStop Self Storage - Milwaukee

Milwaukee, WI

2.5 mi

3420 W Capitol Dr Milwaukee, WI

4.8

Pros: pleasant and helpful customer service, friendly and knowledgeable staff, reasonable prices for storage units, clean and well-maintained facility, good operating hoursCons: limited access after 10 pm

starting at

$49

per month

View all listings

Cheap prices: Starting at $25
  • Average price per listing: $53, average size: 5x5 feet.

  • 25% of listings offer climate control, average size: 5x6 feet.

  • 50% of listings within 8 miles, average price: $40.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

U-Haul Moving & Storage of Menomonee Valley in Milwaukee, WI

U-Haul Moving & Storage of Menomonee Valley

Milwaukee, WI

5.4 mi

3530 W Pierce St Milwaukee, WI

4.1

Pros: lots of security options available, clean and well-maintained facility, easy access to storage units, climate-controlled units availableCons: some issues with online bookings, elevator outages experienced by some users, poor phone customer service reported, issues with entry codes for storage units

starting at

$25

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Extra Space Storage in West Allis, WI

Extra Space Storage

West Allis, WI

6.8 mi

5317 W Burnham St West Allis, WI

4.7

Pros: friendly and helpful staff, professional and courteous service, smooth and easy check-in processCons: frequently broken doors and dirty floors, reports of people living in units, regular and significant price increases, claims of climate control often unmet

starting at

$62

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Extra Space Storage in Milwaukee, WI

Extra Space Storage

Milwaukee, WI

4.1 mi

999 W Mt Vernon Ave Milwaukee, WI

Pros: great location for convenience, good customer service experience, details are explained wellCons: parking spots often rented out, elevator frequently breaks down, trash around elevators; unclean property, regular price increases during rental period, limited cart availability for tenants

starting at

$70

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

One Stop Shop Self Storage in Milwaukee, WI

One Stop Shop Self Storage

Milwaukee, WI

4.5 mi

3742 W Wisconsin Ave Milwaukee, WI

Pros: facility is clean and secure, climate controlled unitsCons: issues with access codes, lack of available carts, unreliable customer service, presence of pests

starting at

$79

per month

View all listings

Larger units: 10x15 and above
  • Average price of a 200 sq ft unit: $190, with some as low as $79.

  • 60% of listings have security cameras, enhancing the safety of stored items.

  • Average host response time: 40 minutes, ensuring quick communication.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

StorageMart in Milwaukee, WI

StorageMart

Milwaukee, WI

5.9 mi

802 E Bay St Milwaukee, WI

4.8

Pros: facility very clean and well-maintained, climate control in storage units, smooth sign-up processCons: elevator frequently out of service, misleading information about fees, limited assistance for inconvenience caused

starting at

$87

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Extra Space Storage in Milwaukee, WI

Extra Space Storage

Milwaukee, WI

5.1 mi

5115 W Good Hope Rd Milwaukee, WI

4.8

Pros: good customer service, helpful and knowledgeable staff

starting at

$145

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Life Storage - Milwaukee in Milwaukee, WI

Life Storage - Milwaukee

Milwaukee, WI

6.5 mi

7440 N 76th St Milwaukee, WI

4.9

Pros: friendly and helpful customer service., clean and well-lit units., convenient access to storage units.Cons: regular rent increases., poorly functioning gate., unavailable or unhelpful staff., reports of sold items without warning., units with mice and cleanliness issues.

starting at

$154

per month

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Life Storage - Milwaukee in Milwaukee, WI

Life Storage - Milwaukee

Milwaukee, WI

0.2 mi

532 E Capitol Dr Milwaukee, WI

4.8

Pros: good customer service and support, units are spacious and clean, safe and secure environmentCons: frequent and significant price hikes, issues with missing belongings, poor response to billing and refunds, facility cleanliness inconsistencies

starting at

$161

per month

View all listings

Smaller units: 5x5 and below
  • Average price for small units: $41. Cheapest unit: $34.

  • Most units offer climate control. 83% of listings include this feature.

  • Average distance: 1.9 miles. Fastest host response time: 0.2 minutes.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Life Storage - Milwaukee in Milwaukee, WI

Life Storage - Milwaukee

Milwaukee, WI

3.3 mi

1131 N 8th St Milwaukee, WI

4.8

starting at

$43

per month

View all listings

Drive-up access with your vehicle
  • Average cost of drive-up units with climate control: $49.33. Most are garages.

  • Average size of drive-up garages: 20x10 feet. Average distance: 2.1 miles.

  • Camera feature units average $56.75. 49% of units offer climate control.

Not affiliated with Neighbor

Red Dot Storage in Milwaukee, WI

Red Dot Storage

Milwaukee, WI

6.3 mi

7330 W Good Hope Rd Milwaukee, WI

4.0

Pros: organized storage units, easy access to units, secure storage facilityCons: rates change frequently, poor snow removal, curfew due to break-ins, customer service not always reliable

starting at

$42

per month

View all listings

Find nearby storage locations

Shorewood, Wisconsin (1 mi)
Glendale, Wisconsin (3 mi)
Milwaukee, Wisconsin (4 mi)
Fox Point, Wisconsin (5 mi)
Brown Deer, Wisconsin (7 mi)
Wauwatosa, Wisconsin (7 mi)
West Allis, Wisconsin (8 mi)
Elm Grove, Wisconsin (10 mi)
Mequon, Wisconsin (10 mi)
Greenfield, Wisconsin (10 mi)

How Neighbor compares to traditional storage facilities

badge w/star

Neighbor

Traditional facilities

Wide variety of sizes

Lowest prices

Highest safety rating

Protection plans

Nationwide availability

Verified hosts

Manage rental online

Storage facility cost comparison

5×10

10×10

10×20

Average storage facility

Whitefish Bay, WI

$66

$106

$170

Neighbor

18 storage spaces nearby

Store Here Self Storage

Milwaukee, WI (0 miles)

$67

$102

$145

Life Storage

Milwaukee, WI (0 miles)

$51

$116

$161

Life Storage

Milwaukee, WI (1 miles)

$59

$104

$176

Storage for Rent in Whitefish Bay, WI

Select storage type

self storage
monthly parking
RV storage
car storage
boat storage
garages
truck parking

What’s the best self storage option for you?

Compare the pros and cons of renting from various storage unit options, including drive-up and interior units

Drive-up Exterior Units
open view of an empty garage

Enclosed drive-up storage units, like garages, have an outdoor entrance

50% of storage spaces in Whitefish Bay have security cameras as an amenity provided by the host

Find drive-up storage
Interior-Access Storage Units
row of indoor storage lockers

Indoor spaces like vacant offices or residential rooms offer increased protection

In Whitefish Bay, 33% of listings do not have stairs leading to the storage space, allowing for easy access

Find indoor storage units
Vehicle Storage Units
view of a half-closed garage with a car inside

Indoor storage units that allow vehicles provide protection over outdoor parking

Residential indoor parking in Whitefish Bay is typically a similar price to surrounding areas

Find car storage units

Alternative Self Storage Facilities near Whitefish Bay

Although storage facilities are available in Whitefish Bay, Wisconsin, Neighbor storage features cheap, close by and secure self storage.

If you'd like information about traditional storage facilities nearby, use the below list for more information:

Life Storage - Milwaukee (0.2 miles)

532 E Capitol Dr Milwaukee, WI

StorageMart (5.9 miles)

802 E Bay St Milwaukee, WI

Store Here Self Storage (0.2 miles)

4300 N Richards St Milwaukee, WI

Extra Space Storage (5.1 miles)

5115 W Good Hope Rd Milwaukee, WI

Life Storage - Milwaukee (6.5 miles)

7440 N 76th St Milwaukee, WI

Life Storage - Milwaukee (3.3 miles)

1131 N 8th St Milwaukee, WI

Regent Mini-Storage (4.3 miles)

4562 W Woolworth Ave Milwaukee, WI

Public Storage (8.3 miles)

8824 W Brown Deer Rd Milwaukee, WI

SmartStop Self Storage - Milwaukee (2.5 miles)

3420 W Capitol Dr Milwaukee, WI

Life Storage (1.3 miles)

4565 N Green Bay Ave Milwaukee, WI

StorageMart (8 miles)

12000 W Silver Spring Dr Milwaukee, WI

Red Dot Storage (6.3 miles)

7330 W Good Hope Rd Milwaukee, WI

Devon Self Storage (7 miles)

2922 S 5th Ct Milwaukee, WI

StorageMart (9.3 miles)

307 W Layton Ave Milwaukee, WI

Storage Rentals Of America (4.4 miles)

1201 W Canal St Milwaukee, WI

Need self storage in Whitefish Bay?

Neighbor is the world’s largest storage marketplace. Call for rates or search online for the cheapest, closest, and safest storage units.

(844) 448-0855